World War I at sea: An Australian witness to the Moldavia’s sinking

3 Posted by - 4 July 2016 - Feature stories

An Australian sapper in the Great War, HP Cornell kept a meticulous record of his wartime experiences in a war diary. Before he’d even reached the front, he witnessed and chronicled the dramatic sinking of the RMS Moldavia. Here, using snippets from this diary and other first-hand accounts, his grandson Larry Cornell revisits this tragic and lesser-known part of World War I naval history. 

The sinking of the armed troopship RMS Moldavia on 23 May 1918 was a sharp reminder that World War I was not coming to a quick end. This was not welcome news to an American public with strong anti-war and isolationist sentiments, still in evidence less than one year since the nation had joined World War I.

Of the 480 American soldiers on board the Moldavia that fateful night in the English Channel, 56 were killed on impact of a German U-boat torpedo.

Sapper H Percy (HP) Cornell of the 1st Field Company Engineers, AIF, my paternal grandfather, witnessed firsthand this U-boat attack from the deck of the troopship, HMAT Persic, one of five troopships being escorted across the Atlantic by the Moldavia from Halifax, Nova Scotia, to London.

In his war diary he reported in dramatic detail the moments of his ‘life or death’ experience that night. These U-Boat attacks came close to sending HP, his fellow sappers, and his war diary to the bottom of the English Channel for all time.

A studio photograph of HP Cornell in uniform, in late 1917. Courtesy Larry Cornell.

A studio photograph of HP Cornell in uniform, in late 1917. Courtesy Larry Cornell.

From Sydney to Halifax, Nova Scotia
HP was 41 years of age and aboard the HMAT Persic when it slipped out of Sydney on Thursday 21 March 1917 on its long journey to Tilbury Docks in London and then, for HP, to the battlefields of the Somme. It took two full months at sea before the ship would enter the River Thames on Thursday 23 May 1918. But before that day, HP and the Persic would face in the cover of darkness the haunting reality of German U-boat 57.

The Persic steamed on from Sydney via, Wellington, New Zealand, through the newly completed Panama Canal and across the Caribbean; on to brief stopovers in Newport News and New York in the USA, and then arriving at Halifax in Nova Scotia, Canada on 10 May 1918 where the Persic caught up with its sister ship HMAT Runic.

Members of the 37th Battalion lining the rails of the HMAT Persic prior to her departure for England. Courtesy AWM, ID PB0837.

Members of the 37th Battalion lining the rails of the HMAT Persic prior to her departure for England. Courtesy AWM, ID PB0837.

Just five months earlier in Halifax, the collision of the French munitions ship Mont Blanc and the Norwegian vessel Imo had created the world’s largest man-made explosion, instantly killing more than 1,600 people (1,900 in total), injuring another 9,000, destroying almost the entire north side of the city and shattering windows 50 miles away.

The port city bustled then, on 6 December 1917, as it did when HP arrived, with ships carrying troops, supplies and munitions across the Atlantic to the Western Front battlefields.

On departing the following day, the devastation created by this massive explosion in Halifax city was clear to HP: “at least nine streets leading to the river and half a mile back are levelled to the ground”.

He was happy when the Persic in convoy with four other troopships, including the Runic, “cleared the (Halifax) harbour and got well out during the afternoon.” They were now being escorted across the Atlantic to London by the RMS Moldavia, an armed troopship with six light naval guns and two anti-aircraft guns.

U-Boat attacks…
Crossing the Atlantic Ocean, the convoy zigzagged continually to disguise its course and minimise the chance of being struck by German submarines that were trying to enforce a blockade against Allied supplies and munitions reaching the Western Front. “Our guard is mounted night and day with loaded rifles as well as the 10 guards on the ordinary posts,” wrote HP.

However, German U-boats weren’t the only threat to life. Apart from rough seas, dark skies, and heavy fogs to create havoc, there was an ongoing threat to the ships in the convoy colliding with each other. Soon after leaving Halifax, on board and on guard on the Persic with HP the night of Wednesday 5 May was Sapper CA Robertson, 2nd Draft, Field Engineers. He reported:

“The convoy ran into such a stiff gale that the Persic almost stood on its head. The old Runic, which was running next to us, got out of control (with) the steering gear breaking down… she came straight for us, and how we missed colliding with her no one knows. Had we bumped in such a raging sea the result would have been disastrous… the end of both vessels. But our luck was in.”

Pages: 1 2


  • avatar
    Peggy Bogar 17 November 2017 - 1:20 pm Reply

    It is lovely to read what someone experienced in reality. Thank you. I appreciate the preservation of such articles.

    • avatar
      Larry 4 February 2018 - 11:32 am Reply

      Thank you Peggy, I couldn’t agree with you more. There is so much personal history that never sees the light of day. Sadly, my grandfather’s diary was never read by anyone until I received it from my Aunty Betty, the youngest child and sister to my father. Why read what the old man did during WWI… ? This I suggest was his children’s standpoint… certainly my father and his siblings never shared such stories with their families including me.

      You must read my first article from his war diary for Inside History, March-April 2016, pp 38-43. This article reveals a secret from WWI that remained so for more than 100 years!

      Thank you for your comments.

  • avatar
    Larry 4 February 2018 - 11:52 am Reply

    Hi Peggy, I couldn’t agree more. So many moving experiences of WWI and of other times that never reach the light of day. Sadly, my grandfather’s WWI diary was never read by his eight children, including my father. I was the first to read his exploits after my Aunty Betty, the youngest sibling gave me his diary just before her death. I never heard of these stories from his children, including my father.

    But you must read the first article that I wrote for Inside History, March-April 2016, pp. that reveals a secret at Pozieres for the first time in over 100 years

  • Leave a reply


    Love history?

    Subscribe to Inside History and never miss an article again.

    Thanks for subscribing to Inside History Magazine